The Express reported that Brady actor Ben Hollingsworth dropped a hint that his character could be the father. Other fans held the shady character Brady responsible for the pregnancy.

The theory suggested Charmaine began seeing him after splitting from Jack, and the babies were his. He also seemed really surprised when Jack confided in him about the pregnancy - some have said a little too shocked. He’d never been mentioned before, and seemed to know a lot about Jack and Charmaine’s relationship. The character of Mike arrived in season 2. Speculation suggests she became pregnant after the split with Jack, but tried to pin the pregnancy on him. This would be unusual, especially when pregnant with twins. She has been pregnant since season 1, and in season 3 there was still no sign of a baby bump. They suggested that Charmaine’s lack of baby bump indicates she isn’t as far along as she says.Īs each new series of Virgin River picks up around 3 - 4 weeks after the end of the previous one, Charmaine would've definitely been showing within that timeline. CheatSheet reported they’d uncovered a scoop exposing Mike as the real father of the twins. Prior to this big reveal, sleuthing fans had been digging among mounting speculation Jack was not the real father.

See all conception & fertility features.